
[DiaryPoint | Reporter Park Bo-young] A Seoul Central District Court civil panel ruled partly in favor of Cuckoo Electronics, Cuckoo Homesys and others on the 20th in a damages suit seeking more than 2 billion won from actor Kim Soo-hyun and his agency, Gold Medalist. The agency was ordered to pay 260,383,561 won to Cuckoo Electronics and 614,794,520 won to Cuckoo Homesys, for a total of 875,178,081 won.
The court dismissed the claims against Kim personally, as well as the claim brought by Cuckoo International Berhad, Cuckoo Homesys’ Malaysian affiliate. Under the ruling, the agency—not the actor himself—is liable for damages.
Termination based on morality clauses and breakdown of trust
The court found that some advertising contracts had been breached through violations of morality clauses, while trust between the parties had broken down under other contracts. It therefore upheld the terminations and ruled that the agency must return part of the endorsement fees to the advertisers.
Cuckoo pulled its ads and filed suit after allegations surfaced that Kim had dated the late Kim Sae-ron when she was a minor. Kim had been the company’s exclusive model for more than a decade. In July this year, police declined to refer the allegations of child welfare law violations and false accusation for prosecution, citing insufficient evidence.
Frombio case distinguishes fee repayment from contractual penalties
Earlier, on Nov. 13, the Suwon District Court ordered Kim’s side to pay about 1.1598 billion won in a 3.96 billion won damages suit filed by Frombio. The company hired Kim as a model in October 2024 and stopped using the ads the following year.
At the time, the court said, “The allegations in this case prevented the defendant from maintaining a positive and trustworthy image, making it impossible to promote the products.” It held the agency responsible for returning the portion of the talent fee covering the period when the ads could not be used. But it did not impose contractual penalties, finding that the damage to Kim’s image was largely caused by third parties spreading false information.
The two rulings assessed the termination of advertising contracts and the extent of damages separately. In the Cuckoo case, the court found violations of morality clauses or a breakdown of trust in individual contracts and assigned partial liability to the agency. In the Frombio case, it treated repayment of fees for the period when ads were suspended separately from contractual penalties. Gold Medalist said it would challenge the fee repayment portion of the Frombio ruling on appeal.
